In my liquid template, I am using: {% assign beatles = article.content | split: "</p>" %} {% for member in beatles %} {{ member }} {% if forloop.index == 3 %} <p>1</p> {% endif %} {% if forloop.index == 6 %} <p>2</p> {% endif %} {% if forloop.index == 9 %} <p>3</p> {% endif %} {% if forloop.index == 12 %} <p>4</p> {% endif %} {% if forloop.index == 15 %} <p>5</p> {% endif %} {% endfor %} What I want to do is have random order for this content appearing (rather than 1 always appearing after the third paragraph instance for example. But the values should be unique - so each number does not appear twice. Any idea on how I can achieve this?